Free calculator
I-9 fine calculator
Enter how many Forms I-9 you should have on file and how many have substantive violations. The calculator shows your violation rate and the penalty range those forms could carry.
Enter your form counts to estimate the range. Violations cannot exceed the number of forms.
An estimate of the statutory range, not a prediction. ICE sets the base fine from your violation rate and offense history. Nothing you enter leaves your browser.
How I-9 paperwork fines are calculated
Paperwork penalties are assessed per form. Each Form I-9 with a substantive violation can be fined within a range set by regulation, whether or not the employee is authorized to work. That is why a small error repeated across a workforce becomes a large number.
The calculator multiplies your count of forms with violations by the minimum and maximum per-form amounts. The defaults are the figures from the adjustment published on January 2, 2025. They change with inflation, so the fields are editable.
The five factors
ICE adjusts its base fine using five statutory factors. Each is scored as aggravating (plus 5%), mitigating (minus 5%), or neutral, for a combined swing of up to 25% in either direction. A documented internal audit and prompt corrections support the good faith factor.
How to bring the number down
The estimate falls when the violation count falls. Correct what can be corrected using the I-9 audit checklist, and destroy forms that are past their date with the retention calculator. For how inspections unfold, read I-9 penalties and fines and what to do with a Notice of Inspection.
This calculator applies general federal rules and is not legal advice. Confirm unusual situations with USCIS guidance or counsel.
Frequently asked questions
How much is the fine per I-9 violation?
The regulation at 8 CFR 274a.10 sets a range per form for paperwork violations. The amounts printed in the January 2, 2025 adjustment are $288 to $2,861. DHS adjusts them for inflation each year, so check the latest Federal Register notice and edit the fields above if they have changed.
How does ICE decide where in the range a fine falls?
ICE sets a base fine from the percentage of forms with violations and whether it is a first, second, or later offense. It then applies five factors: business size, good faith, seriousness, whether unauthorized workers were involved, and history. Each can raise or lower the base fine by 5%.
What counts as a substantive violation?
Examples include a missing Form I-9, a missing employee or employer signature, no citizenship status box checked, and a Section 2 with no documents recorded. Technical errors become substantive if they are not corrected within the time ICE allows.
Does this cover fines for hiring unauthorized workers?
No. Knowingly hiring or continuing to employ an unauthorized worker carries separate, higher penalties that increase with each offense. This calculator covers paperwork violations only.
More I-9 calculators
All calculatorsI-9 deadline calculator
Section 1, Section 2, and E-Verify due dates from a start date.
Open calculator Free calculatorI-9 reverification calculator
The reverify-by date and when to remind the employee.
Open calculator Free calculatorI-9 retention calculator
The earliest date a form can be destroyed.
Open calculatorFind out your real violation count.
An I-9 audit replaces the guess with a number, and gives your team a list to correct.