Skip to content

Audits

How to Correct I-9 Errors Without Making Them Worse

How to correct Form I-9 errors the way USCIS describes: who may correct each section, the line-through method, when to use a new form, and how to write a memo to file.

Updated November 16, 20265 min read

Who may correct what

Part of the formWho corrects it
Section 1The employee. A preparer or translator may help and should also initial and date.
Section 2The employer, ideally the person who completed it
Supplement BThe employer

USCIS guidance is explicit that employers may only correct errors in Section 2 or Supplement B. If you spot a Section 1 error, ask the employee to fix it. If they have left the company, attach a memo describing the error.

The correction method

  1. Draw a single line through the incorrect information so it stays readable.
  2. Enter the correct information nearby.
  3. Initial and date the correction, using the date you make it.

On an electronic form, the system should record who made the change and when. That audit trail does the same job as initials and a date.

What to do for each kind of error

ErrorFix
A field is wrong or blank in Section 2Line through or complete it, then initial and date
Many errors in one sectionRedo that section on a new form and attach it to the original
A whole section was never completedComplete it now with today's date and attach an explanation
Section 2 was based on unacceptable documentsAsk the employee for acceptable documents and complete a new Section 2. Keep the old form attached.
The form was completed lateLeave the dates as they are. Attach a memo. Lateness cannot be undone.
No Form I-9 existsComplete a new one immediately with current dates and a memo
Correction fluid was used in the pastAttach a signed and dated note explaining what happened

How to write a memo to file

A memo explains what the form itself cannot. Keep it short and factual:

  • The employee's name and the form it relates to.
  • What was found, and when.
  • What was done about it, and when.
  • The name, signature, and date of the person writing it.

Attach it to the form. Good memos are part of what shows good faith if the forms are ever inspected.

What never to do

  • Do not backdate a signature or a correction.
  • Do not erase, obscure, or use correction fluid.
  • Do not discard the original form after completing a new one.
  • Do not ask for new documents from an employee whose form is merely incomplete, unless the documents recorded were not acceptable.
  • Do not correct only some employees' forms. Apply the same review to everyone.

Corrections are step five of the I-9 audit checklist. Errors left alone are what the I-9 fine calculator counts.

Frequently asked questions

Can an employer correct Section 1 of Form I-9?

No. Only the employee may correct Section 1. The employer may correct Section 2 and Supplement B.

Should I complete a new I-9 to fix mistakes?

Only for major errors, such as a blank section or unacceptable documents. Otherwise correct the original. If you do complete a new form, keep the old one attached.

Can I use white-out on a Form I-9?

No. If correction fluid has already been used, attach a signed and dated note explaining it.

Can a late I-9 be fixed?

The lateness cannot be corrected. Leave the true dates in place and attach a memo explaining the delay.

Sources

This guide is general information for employers and is not legal advice. Rules and forms change. Confirm details with USCIS or your counsel before acting.

See what a compliance scan would flag.

Explore three findings from an illustrative I-9 review and what a reviewer would check next.