A finding for every issue
Each item names the form, the section, what is wrong, and what a reviewer should check against the source document.
I-9 audits
An I-9 audit reviews every form you hold for the errors that lead to fines. You get a prioritized list of findings, and your HR team knows exactly what to correct and how.
Most employers have never had every Form I-9 looked at in one pass. Forms are completed by different people, at different locations, over many years, and the errors accumulate quietly. An audit puts all of them through the same review.
The review follows the same order as our I-9 audit checklist: reconcile forms against your employee roster, check each section, then sort what was found by how serious it is.
Findings are only useful if someone can act on them. Each one is tied to a form, a section, and a next step.
Each item names the form, the section, what is wrong, and what a reviewer should check against the source document.
Substantive problems such as a missing signature are separated from technical ones, so your team starts with what matters most.
Uncertain entries are flagged for human review instead of being guessed at. Your team makes the call.
Who may correct what, how to line through, initial, and date, and when a memo to file is the right answer.
Forms past their retention date are listed so they can be destroyed on a documented schedule.
What was reviewed, when, and what changed. That record is evidence of good faith.
Bring together paper forms, scanned copies, and digital records from each hiring location, with a roster from payroll.
Every form is screened for missing fields, dates that do not line up, and incomplete document details.
Flagged entries are compared with the source form. Findings are confirmed, ranked, and written up.
Each finding is routed to the person responsible, and the correction is kept alongside the original form.
There is no required schedule for internal audits, but some moments call for one: before or after a merger or acquisition, when you change HR or payroll systems, after turnover in the team that completes Section 2, when you move from paper to electronic forms, or when it has simply been more than a year.
The stakes are per form. Paperwork penalties are assessed on each form with a substantive violation, whether or not every employee is authorized to work. How I-9 penalties are calculated explains the factors, and what triggers an I-9 audit explains why three business days of notice is not enough time to start from scratch.
An internal audit is not legal advice and does not guarantee the outcome of a government inspection. For open inspections or suspected unauthorized employment, involve immigration counsel.
An I-9 audit is a review of an employer's Forms I-9 for completeness and accuracy. An internal audit is voluntary and run by or for the employer. A government audit is an inspection by ICE that begins with a Notice of Inspection.
Missing forms, blank or late signatures and dates, incomplete document information, wrong document combinations, late Section 2 completion, missed reverifications, outdated form editions, and forms kept beyond their retention date.
It depends on the number of forms and how they are stored. Scanned or digital forms move faster than paper held at several locations. Reconciling against payroll first shortens the whole process.
Yes, if the sample is chosen by neutral criteria. Do not select forms based on citizenship status or national origin. Many employers review everything the first time and sample afterwards.
Your team corrects them following USCIS guidance. Employers may correct Section 2 and Supplement B, and employees correct Section 1. Nothing is backdated or concealed.
A practical checklist for reviewing every form: what to pull, what to check in each section, and how to correct what you find.
Read guide AuditsWhy employers get selected, what a Notice of Inspection requires, and the notices that can follow.
Read guide AuditsThe types of violation, how fines are calculated per form, and the five factors that move them up or down.
Read guideOpen the sample compliance scan and explore three findings from an illustrative review.