Skip to content

Audits

I-9 Audit Checklist: How to Run an Internal Review

A step-by-step I-9 audit checklist for HR teams. Build your employee roster, review Section 1, Section 2, and Supplement B, correct errors the right way, and document the audit.

Updated November 16, 20268 min read

Before you start

An internal I-9 audit is a voluntary review of your own forms. Done well, it finds problems while you can still fix them and shows good faith if the government ever inspects. Done badly, it creates new violations. Decide three things up front.

  • Scope. Review every form, or a sample chosen by neutral criteria. Do not select forms based on an employee's citizenship status or national origin.
  • Reviewer. Pick someone who understands the form and was not the person who completed most of the Section 2s.
  • Record. Keep a written log of what you reviewed, what you found, and how each item was resolved.

Step 1: Reconcile forms against payroll

  1. Pull a list of every current employee hired after November 6, 1986, with hire dates.
  2. Pull terminated employees whose forms are still inside the retention period. The I-9 retention calculator gives the date for each one.
  3. Match each person to a Form I-9. List anyone without a form.
  4. Set aside forms that are past their retention date so they can be purged on a documented schedule.

A missing form is a substantive violation. If you find one, complete a new Form I-9 now with current dates. Do not backdate it. Attach a short signed memo explaining when the gap was found and what was done.

Step 2: Check Section 1

  • Legal name, address, and date of birth are filled in.
  • Exactly one citizenship or immigration status box is checked.
  • A USCIS or A-Number, I-94 number, or foreign passport number is entered where the chosen status requires one, with the work authorization expiration date if applicable.
  • The employee signed and dated the form no later than the first day of employment.
  • Supplement A is attached if a preparer or translator helped.

Only the employee can correct Section 1. Ask them to line through the error, enter the correct information, and initial and date the change. If they no longer work for you, note the error in a memo instead.

Step 3: Check Section 2

  • Documents recorded are one from List A, or one from List B and one from List C. See the full lists of acceptable documents.
  • Each document has a title, issuing authority, number, and expiration date where one exists.
  • The first day of employment is filled in.
  • The employer or authorized representative signed, dated, and printed their name, title, and the business name and address.
  • Section 2 was completed within three business days of the first day of work for pay.
  • If documents were examined remotely, the alternative procedure box is checked and copies are on file.

Late completion cannot be fixed after the fact, but it should be explained. Leave the original date in place and attach a memo. Changing the date is the mistake that makes a late form look like a fraudulent one. The I-9 deadline calculator shows when each form was due.

Step 4: Check reverifications and rehires

For every employee whose work authorization had an expiration date, confirm that reverification happened on Supplement B on or before that date. Check too that nobody was reverified who should not have been. U.S. citizens, permanent residents who presented a Form I-551, and List B identity documents are never reverified.

Step 5: Correct and document

  1. Draw a single line through the incorrect information.
  2. Enter the correct information next to it.
  3. Initial and date the correction with today's date.
  4. For a section with many errors, complete that section on a new form and staple it to the original.
  5. Write a brief audit memo for the file: who reviewed, when, what was corrected.

If correction fluid has already been used on a form, USCIS guidance is to attach a signed and dated note explaining what happened. The goal throughout is a file that shows its history plainly. How to correct I-9 errors covers each type of mistake.

After the audit

Look for patterns. If one location produces most of the late Section 2s, that is a training problem. If expiring work authorizations keep being missed, that is a tracking problem that I-9 compliance software solves by tracking each expiration date. And if the stack is too large to review by hand, an outside I-9 audit can scan every form and hand your team a short queue of findings.

Frequently asked questions

How often should an employer audit its I-9s?

There is no required schedule. Many employers review annually, and again after a merger, a change of HR system, or turnover in the team that completes the forms.

Can I fix a Section 1 error myself?

No. USCIS guidance says employers may only correct Section 2 and Supplement B. Section 1 corrections must be made by the employee.

Should I complete a new I-9 when I find errors?

Usually you correct the existing form. A new form is appropriate when the original is missing, when a whole section was left blank, or when Section 2 was completed from unacceptable documents. Keep the old form attached to the new one.

Does an internal audit protect us from fines?

It does not grant immunity. It does reduce the number of open errors, and good-faith effort is one of the factors considered when penalties are set.

Sources

This guide is general information for employers and is not legal advice. Rules and forms change. Confirm details with USCIS or your counsel before acting.

See what a compliance scan would flag.

Explore three findings from an illustrative I-9 review and what a reviewer would check next.