The three forms side by side
| Form I-9 | Form W-4 | Form W-9 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full name | Employment Eligibility Verification | Employee's Withholding Certificate | Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification |
| Agency | USCIS (Department of Homeland Security) | IRS | IRS |
| Purpose | Confirms identity and authorization to work | Tells the employer how much income tax to withhold | Gives a payer the contractor's taxpayer ID for year-end reporting |
| Completed by | Every employee, plus the employer | Every employee | Independent contractors and vendors |
| Deadline | Section 1 by day one, Section 2 within three business days | At hire, before the first payroll | Before the first payment |
| Documents needed | Yes, from the Lists of Acceptable Documents | No | No |
I-9 vs W-4
Both are completed by a new employee, usually on the same day, which is why they get confused. The W-4 is about tax and involves no proof. The I-9 is about the right to work and requires the employer to examine original documents and sign under penalty of perjury. Errors on a W-4 affect a pay cheque. Errors on an I-9 can lead to civil penalties.
I-9 vs W-9
These two never apply to the same worker. An employee completes an I-9. An independent contractor gives you a W-9, and you do not complete an I-9 for them.
Classification decides which form applies, and the form does not decide the classification. If a worker treated as a contractor is really an employee, an I-9 was required from their first day. And a business may not use a contract to obtain the labor of someone it knows is not authorized to work.
The new-hire paperwork order
- Offer accepted.
- Employee completes Section 1 of Form I-9 and Form W-4, on or before the first day.
- Employer examines documents and completes Section 2 within three business days.
- If enrolled, the employer creates the E-Verify case by the same deadline.
For field-by-field help, see how to fill out Form I-9 correctly.
Frequently asked questions
Do independent contractors need to fill out an I-9?
No. Form I-9 is required for employees. A business does not complete one for a genuine independent contractor, though it may not knowingly use contract labor from someone unauthorized to work.
Is the I-9 a tax form?
No. It is an immigration form issued by USCIS. It has nothing to do with tax withholding or reporting.
Do I send the I-9 or W-4 to the government?
No. The employer keeps both. Form I-9 must be produced within three business days if an authorized officer requests it.
Sources
This guide is general information for employers and is not legal advice. Rules and forms change. Confirm details with USCIS or your counsel before acting.