What a Notice of Inspection is
A Notice of Inspection (NOI) is the written notice U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement serves to begin a Form I-9 inspection. It is an administrative request for records. It requires you to produce your Forms I-9, and by regulation you receive at least three business days to do so.
It is usually accompanied by a subpoena for supporting documents: a list of current and terminated employees with hire and termination dates, payroll records, business ownership information, and details of any E-Verify participation.
A three-day response plan
Day 0: the notice arrives
- Note the date and time of service and who received it.
- Call immigration counsel. Do not sign a waiver of the three-day period.
- Name one person to coordinate the response.
Day 1: gather
- Build the employee list the notice asks for from payroll.
- Pull the Form I-9 for every current employee, and for former employees still inside the retention period.
- Set aside forms that are past retention. Discuss with counsel whether they need to be produced.
Day 2: review
- Check the set is complete against the list. Identify any missing forms.
- Do not make silent changes. Any correction made now must be dated with today's date and follow the correction rules.
- Make a full copy of everything you will hand over.
Day 3: produce
- Deliver the forms and records as counsel advises, and get a receipt.
- Keep your copy set and a log of what was produced.
If three days is not enough, ask for an extension in writing. ICE may grant one, but it does not have to.
What comes after
ICE reviews the forms and issues one or more notices. Technical or procedural failures come with at least ten business days to correct. Substantive violations can lead to a Warning Notice or a Notice of Intent to Fine, which you may contest by requesting a hearing within 30 days. Each notice is explained in what triggers an I-9 audit, and the arithmetic in I-9 penalties and fines.
Being ready before it happens
Three days is enough to assemble good records and nowhere near enough to repair bad ones. Employers that respond well ran an internal audit beforehand, purge on schedule, and can retrieve every form quickly. Estimate where you stand with the I-9 fine calculator, or have an I-9 audit done.
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to respond to a Notice of Inspection?
At least three business days from service to produce the Forms I-9 requested.
Can I correct I-9s after receiving a Notice of Inspection?
Corrections must be open and dated when they are made. Backdating or concealing changes can turn a paperwork problem into a fraud allegation. Take legal advice first.
Does a Notice of Inspection mean ICE will visit the workplace?
Not necessarily. An I-9 inspection is a review of records. Many employers deliver the forms to an ICE office.
Sources
This guide is general information for employers and is not legal advice. Rules and forms change. Confirm details with USCIS or your counsel before acting.