Skip to content

Recordkeeping

Form I-9 for Rehires: New Form or Supplement B?

The I-9 rules for rehired employees: when you can reuse the original form with Supplement B, when a new Form I-9 is needed, and how rehiring affects reverification and retention.

Updated November 16, 20264 min read

The three-year rule

When a former employee comes back, you have a choice if you rehire them within three years of the date their previous Form I-9 was completed. You may either complete a new Form I-9, or reuse the previous one by completing Supplement B. After three years, a new Form I-9 is required.

SituationWhat to do
Rehired within three years, still authorized to workSupplement B with the rehire date, or a new Form I-9
Rehired within three years, work authorization has expiredSupplement B with the rehire date and reverification, or a new Form I-9
Rehired more than three years after the original formNew Form I-9
Original form cannot be foundNew Form I-9

Using Supplement B for a rehire

  1. Confirm the original form is complete and that the person is still authorized to work based on what it shows.
  2. Enter the employee's name and the date of rehire on Supplement B.
  3. If their employment authorization has expired, examine a current List A or List C document and record it. See I-9 reverification.
  4. Sign and date.
  5. If the original was completed on an edition that is no longer valid, use Supplement B from the current edition and attach it.

Many employers simply complete a new Form I-9 for every rehire. It is one rule for everyone and avoids hunting for old forms. If you do, the usual deadlines apply from the rehire date.

When someone is not a rehire

No new form or Supplement B is needed for an employee who is continuing in employment. That covers people returning from approved leave, a temporary layoff, a strike, or seasonal employment where there is a reasonable expectation of return, and employees transferred between units of the same employer.

Rehires and retention

A form reused for a rehire belongs to a current employee again and must be kept. When the person leaves for the last time, work out the destruction date with the I-9 retention calculator and the retention rule. E-Verify employers should also check E-Verify's own guidance on rehires before deciding whether a new case is needed.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a new I-9 for a rehire?

Not always. If you rehire within three years of the date the previous Form I-9 was completed, you may complete Supplement B on that form instead. After three years you need a new form.

Does a seasonal employee need a new I-9 each season?

Not if they are continuing in employment with a reasonable expectation of returning. If the employment genuinely ended, treat them as a rehire.

What date goes on Supplement B for a rehire?

The date of rehire, along with the reviewer's signature and the date they signed.

Sources

This guide is general information for employers and is not legal advice. Rules and forms change. Confirm details with USCIS or your counsel before acting.

See what a compliance scan would flag.

Explore three findings from an illustrative I-9 review and what a reviewer would check next.