The three-year rule
When a former employee comes back, you have a choice if you rehire them within three years of the date their previous Form I-9 was completed. You may either complete a new Form I-9, or reuse the previous one by completing Supplement B. After three years, a new Form I-9 is required.
| Situation | What to do |
|---|---|
| Rehired within three years, still authorized to work | Supplement B with the rehire date, or a new Form I-9 |
| Rehired within three years, work authorization has expired | Supplement B with the rehire date and reverification, or a new Form I-9 |
| Rehired more than three years after the original form | New Form I-9 |
| Original form cannot be found | New Form I-9 |
Using Supplement B for a rehire
- Confirm the original form is complete and that the person is still authorized to work based on what it shows.
- Enter the employee's name and the date of rehire on Supplement B.
- If their employment authorization has expired, examine a current List A or List C document and record it. See I-9 reverification.
- Sign and date.
- If the original was completed on an edition that is no longer valid, use Supplement B from the current edition and attach it.
Many employers simply complete a new Form I-9 for every rehire. It is one rule for everyone and avoids hunting for old forms. If you do, the usual deadlines apply from the rehire date.
When someone is not a rehire
No new form or Supplement B is needed for an employee who is continuing in employment. That covers people returning from approved leave, a temporary layoff, a strike, or seasonal employment where there is a reasonable expectation of return, and employees transferred between units of the same employer.
Rehires and retention
A form reused for a rehire belongs to a current employee again and must be kept. When the person leaves for the last time, work out the destruction date with the I-9 retention calculator and the retention rule. E-Verify employers should also check E-Verify's own guidance on rehires before deciding whether a new case is needed.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a new I-9 for a rehire?
Not always. If you rehire within three years of the date the previous Form I-9 was completed, you may complete Supplement B on that form instead. After three years you need a new form.
Does a seasonal employee need a new I-9 each season?
Not if they are continuing in employment with a reasonable expectation of returning. If the employment genuinely ended, treat them as a rehire.
What date goes on Supplement B for a rehire?
The date of rehire, along with the reviewer's signature and the date they signed.
Sources
- USCIS: Completing Supplement B, Reverification and Rehires
- USCIS: Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification
This guide is general information for employers and is not legal advice. Rules and forms change. Confirm details with USCIS or your counsel before acting.